Deliberating Chile's Constitutional Convention

Deliberating Chile's Constitutional Convention

In May 2023, Michael Neblo, IDEA's director, got a call from Matías Díaz, a program officer at Fundación Piensa in Chile. Matías had read Michael's book about Deliberative Town Halls (DTHs) in the U.S. and wanted to know whether IDEA would advise Fundación Piensa on adapting the process for Chile. Chile was on its third attempt to draft a new constitution since the end of the Pinochet dictatorship. The first attempt, under President Michelle Bachelet, stalled when Sebastián Piñera took office. The second, which had broad public participation, was rejected during Gabriel Boric's term. The third process was more restricted, and Fundación Piensa saw a risk that it would fail too.

“What we wanted to know was what the real, full range of voters thought,” Matías said, “and so that is why we thought that Deliberative Town Halls, which use scientifically representative samples, might be the best option for us.”

Michael agreed and was excited for the chance to hold a DTH in Latin America, especially in a country like Chile.

“Chile is geographically polarized in a way somewhat similar to the US, but of course, it's also an incredibly rare research opportunity to get citizen input into the process of drafting an entirely new constitution,” Michael said.

IDEA and Fundación Piensa became partners. Rather than cover the entire constitutional proposal, the team focused on two especially salient issues within it and held one DTH on each. Time was short. Much of the proposal was still in early draft form, and by the time the DTHs were held and the data analyzed, the results could only reach the Constitutional Council as it made final revisions to the proposal voters would decide on.

Like all DTHs, both events recruited a demographically representative sample of constituents, sent accessible, nonpartisan background materials in advance, focused on a single issue per session, and used an independent, neutral moderator. Over the summer, the team worked with a survey firm to recruit participants and trained volunteers to help moderate. In September and October, as the Constitutional Council rushed to revise the proposal, 3,400 Chilean citizens of every age, class, and region came together online with Constitutional Council members from different parties for Chile's first-ever series of DTHs.

Chile's first DTH on pension reform

Maria Pardo

In September 2023, a representative sample of 728 citizens took part in Chile's first-ever DTH, which focused on the country's pension system. Citizens were first surveyed on their political views and the pension system, then randomly assigned to a treatment or control group to avoid selection bias. The treatment group received neutral information about pensions and an invitation to the DTH. Maximiliano Duarte Cortés, a program officer at Fundación Piensa, hosted the event, which featured Constitutional Council members María Pardo of Convergencia Social and Sebastián Figueroa of the Partido Republicano.

Citizens posed high-quality questions about the pension system.

One participant asked, “If the private system has already failed, why are we still considering a private administration system?”

Another asked, “Why aren't two mechanisms created? That is, a private and individual mechanism and a shared one? And so, the citizen and/or contributor is the one who decides where to distribute their resources.”

What the pension reform research found

Chart 1: Changes in policy support

pension

After the DTH, disagreement with creating a common fund for low pensions rose from 48 percent to 53 percent, and agreement rose from 30 percent to 37 percent.

Chart 2: Trust levels before and after the DTH

Trust rate

Before the DTH, participants reported widespread distrust of institutions such as the National Congress and the Constitutional Council. After the event, extreme distrust dropped significantly. The share reporting no trust at all in the Constitutional Council fell by over 10 percentage points. Many participants moved from no trust to little trust, a shift away from extreme negativity that could become a foundation for rebuilding confidence.

Chart 3: Participants' perception of information before and after the DTH

Informed decisions

Participants also came away with a better understanding of the constitutional process and its importance for the country's development. The number who felt “fairly informed” about the process rose by 10 percent, and the number who agreed that “people like me are qualified to participate in politics” rose by 6 percent. Distrust remains a powerful force in Chile, but the DTH showed how inclusive, authentic dialogue can help restore trust in representative institutions. When people have the chance to be heard, they can begin to trust again.

Chile's second DTH on political rights

On October 16, 2023, IDEA and Fundación Piensa held a second DTH on how the new constitution should guarantee political rights. It featured two other Constitutional Council members, Paloma Zúñiga of Revolución Democrática and Arturo Phillips of the Unión Demócrata Independiente. For more than an hour, participants discussed the future of Chile's political system, including gender parity, electoral reform, and the structure of government.

Participants asked questions such as these:

“How can we ensure that the new constitution is democratic and promotes citizen participation?”

“How should Chile's political system be designed to ensure stability and avoid fragmentation?”

“How can the representation of women, indigenous peoples, and minorities in general be ensured in this new constitution?”

Despite deep ideological divides, the Constitutional Council members and the constituents watching, asking questions, and commenting listened to each other. Many disagreed, but they did so with respect and a genuine desire to understand the other side.

Chile

What the political rights research found

Distrust in the Constitutional Council fell by 15 percentage points, and people who had felt disconnected from the political process began to feel their voices mattered. In a climate of polarization, the event showed that citizens and politicians can disagree on basic issues and still be willing to reach agreements in a friendly, deliberative spirit.

Beyond shifts on specific policies, the DTH showed the potential of well-designed deliberation to help heal a fractured society. Chileans from all levels of society came together to listen, reflect, and find common ground rather than shout over each other, a small but meaningful step toward rebuilding trust in their democracy. Participants left with a better understanding of the issues and renewed hope that dialogue and progress are possible even in a polarized environment.

“It was incredible to watch so many citizens engage meaningfully with their elected constituents. This is especially powerful considering our national context. There is a lot of distrust of politics in general. In the case of the last constitutional process, people didn't feel that the process represented them and didn't follow the previous one. This experiment shows us how you can reconnect people with politics and proves that if you gave people the right tools to participate, they would do it,” said Manuel Diaz.

What happened after the DTHs

The reports analyzing constituent opinion were not finished until the final week before the proposal was finalized and placed on official ballots, which left no time to debate or revise the proposal based on citizens' feedback. Voters rejected the 2023 draft constitution in December 2023. Many in Chile, including members of the National Congress, believe there may be opportunities to pass legislation on individual reforms that IDEA's analysis showed have strong support.

Reports and further reading